REM's track Belong from their March 1991 album, Out of Time, bears more than a passing resemblance to Robert Plant's In The Mood, from his 1983 album The Principle of Moments. Similarities include the same key (G major), close tempos (ITM: 100 bpm, B: 103 bpm), melodies that emphasize movement between the major third and fourth degrees of the root scale, progressions that cycle between I-IV or I-Isus4 (two bars each), and fade-in intros that feature comparable bass parts and 16th note patterns on a closed hi-hat (In The Mood's drums were played by Phil Collins). [Thanks to Justin Schack for suggesting this comparison.]
Other examples of the I-IV or I-Isus4 progression over a root pedal-tone can be found in the following songs:
Sweet Emotion by Aerosmith (key: A)
40 by U2 (key: A)
One Thing by Finger Eleven (key: Ab)
Take A Picture by filter (key A)
Dizz Knee Lane by Dada (key: D)
English indie rock band Arctic Monkeys' track Knee Socks (released September 9, 2013) bears some resemblance to hip hop artist/fashion designer Kanye West's Gorgeous (released November 22, 2010). Both songs feature a prominent electric guitar riff and melodies that utilize a pentatonic minor scale in ascending order 1-b3-4-5 (Knee Socks in E minor: E, G, A, B; Gorgeous in C# minor: C#, E, F#, G#). Gorgeous actually utilizes elements of the 1969 Turtles' single You Showed Me, which was written by Roger McGuinn and Gene Clark of the Byrds. Compare Gorgeous (:47) and Knee Socks (1:58). [Thanks to Alphabet Omnimedia Group for suggesting this comparison!]
In 1977, the Starland Vocal Band won a Grammy Award for "Best Arrangement for Voices" for its sexually-suggestive number-one single Afternoon Delight (released April 1976). SVB hailed from Washington, D.C. That same year, singer-songwriter Jason Mraz was born in nearby Virginia. Coincidence? The bridge to Mraz's love song I Won't Give Up (released January 3, 2012) features the same chord progression (2-5 or F#min7->Bmaj for IWGU, and Gmin7->Cmaj for AD), vocal melody, and harmony as the pre-chorus to Afternoon Delight. Compare IWGU (around 2:16) starting with the lines "I don't wanna be someone who walks away so easily, I'm here to stay and make the difference I can make", to AD (around :27) with the line "When everything's a little clearer in the light of day." Hard not to picture Ron Burgundy's news team singing it!
British singer-songwriter Jessie J released her track Price Tag on January 28, 2011. Artist and actress Miley Cyrus released her track We Can't Stop on June 3, 2013. The two previously collaborated on Miley's hit Party in the U.S.A., which Jessie co-wrote with Dr. Luke and Claude Kelly. We Can't Stop (at 80 bpm) and Price Tag (at 93 bpm) have the exact same 1-3-6-4 chord progression only a half-step apart (WCS in the key of E major: E major, G# minor, C# minor, A major; and PT in the key of F major: F major, A minor, D minor, Bb major). Compare Price Tag (:16) to We Can't Stop (:11).
Danish singer-songwriter Karen Marie Ørsted better known as MØ, officially released her track Pilgrim in March 2013, the same month as Lorde's Royals. However, Pitchfork writer Larry Fitzmaurice reviewed Mo's track the previous October. The two songs share a drumbeat, handclap/fingersnaps on the second and fourth beats and feature raw female vocals. The similarities seem to end there.
As a musician and composer, I’m often struck by similarities between pop songs. If you’ve ever listened to a tune on the radio and thought to yourself, “this sounds really familiar,” or “what does this melody remind me of,” (or more bluntly, “this song is a rip-off of …”) then you have shared in the experience.