Hard to pinpoint this one, but both songs involve dancing, fantasy, both start with a I - IV progression, the verse bass line in both is tonic-fifth-major 3rd, and other than that, you just have to listen and feel... hard to put into words, but it's there.
As the World Falls Down (:07) VS Dance With Me (:24)
I don't know how to describe the similarities, but they are there, at least I think so. I know the song "Just Like Heaven" in and out, but Another Girl Another Planet is new to me, and every time I hear it, I can't help but hear the similarities.
This one you just have to listen to. It's an excellent example of mining a previously successful formula to produce a hit. The tempos are almost the same, 114/117bpm. The bass line in both songs is straight eighth-notes. The keyboard verse riff in CQ is rhythmically identical to the verse riff in BJ, the guitar fill in CQ verses is similar to the guitar riffage in the middle section of BJ, and the tom-tom fills at the end of verses and choruses in CQ are ridiculously similar to the tom-tom fills in BJ. The choruses are pretty close thematically (i to iv), but CQ adds in a few extra chords. Really, it's all about the rhythm, the feel. Very clever reverse-engineering!
Both songs start with a similar percussive pattern, and the keys are not identical, but within a half-step apart (Ebish, E). "Rock Your Baby" was released in 1974, and "Heart of Glass" in 1979. The "B" section of "Heart of Glass" is clearly influenced by "Rock Your Baby". Both lyric melody lines start on the same note, and although RYB has a longer, more intricate chord pattern, technically, all the chords of HOG are in there. Start @ 1:43 in "Heart of Glass" for comparison.
As a musician and composer, I’m often struck by similarities between pop songs. If you’ve ever listened to a tune on the radio and thought to yourself, “this sounds really familiar,” or “what does this melody remind me of,” (or more bluntly, “this song is a rip-off of …”) then you have shared in the experience.