Singer-songwriter and Harvard alum Rivers Cuomo of the alt rock group Weezer has been known to keep notebooks full of popular songs in an attempt to discern the "formula" for a hit. It's unclear whether or not Supertramp's It's Raining Again, which was released in October 1982, was ever contained in those notebooks, but the verse melody for Weezer's Island In The Sun, which was released on October 29, 2001 definitely bears a strong resemblance to the tune (compare both songs around :18). Likewise, Island In The Sun's familiar chord progression (E minor, A minor, D, G OR 6-2-5-1) can be found in the chorus of Talk Talk's It's My Life (though the latter is in the key of C instead of G).
Ryan Adams pulls off a subtle tribute to a song he would go on to cover, Oasis' "Wonderwall". Not only does Adams sing "I'm too scared to know how I feel about you now", but the vocal melody when he sings this line sounds just like "There are many things that I, would like to say to you..."
La Cienega Just Smiled (1:10) VS Wonderwall (1:33)
As a musician and composer, I’m often struck by similarities between pop songs. If you’ve ever listened to a tune on the radio and thought to yourself, “this sounds really familiar,” or “what does this melody remind me of,” (or more bluntly, “this song is a rip-off of …”) then you have shared in the experience.