The verse melody for British pianist/composer Joe Jackson's 1982 release, Breaking Us in Two (key: F# major), is nearly identical to the intro/verse melody for Beatles' proteges and tragic heroes Badfinger's 1971 hit Day After Day (key: F major), which features performances by George Harrison on slide guitar and Leon Russell on piano. Musically, the first five notes of both melodies follow the same pattern (3-4-5-1-b7), albeit a half-step apart. Compare DAD's opening riff and line "I remember finding out about you" to BUiT's "Don't you feel like trying something new?"
Train's country/folk-pop duet Bruises featuring Ashley Monroe (released November 9, 2012) bears resemblance to both Madonna's Crazy for You (released March 1985) and John Denver's 1966 composition Leaving On A Jet Plane. Verses for both Bruises (key: D major) and Crazy for You (key: E major) share a I-IV-V (or major 1-4-5) chord progression (though a whole step apart), and verse melodies for both songs hew to a similar major pentatonic scale (compare CFY's line "Two-by-two their bodies become one" with B's line "Haven't seen you since high school"). Likewise, the chorus melody for Bruises and verse melody for Denver's Leaving On A Jet Place (key: G major) follow a similar fifth to major third movement in the root scale (LOAJP's line "So kiss me and smile for me [...] and B's "These bruises make for better conversation [...]"). Check out Crazy for You (:27) and Bruises (:10).
Late American singer-songwriter and musician John Weldon Cale, better known as J.J. Cale influenced artists on both sides of the Atlantic with his brand of laid-back blues (e.g. Clapton, Knopfler, Waylon Jennings, Jerry Garcia). Cale's River Runs Deep (released in 1972) seems to have inspired Dire Strait's Six Blade Knife (released only six-years later in 1978). Both songs are in the key of A minor, and have close tempos (RRD: 113bpm, SBK: 118), and similar chord progressions typical of the genre: River Runs Deep follows a i-IV (or minor 1-4) , while Six Blade Knife follows a i-III-IV (minor 1-3-4). Have a listen, RRD (:44) and SBK (1:57). [Thanks to Laurence Groffman for this one!]
Canadian indie-rock darlings Arcade Fire's latest single Here Comes The Night Time (released September 2013) seems to be channeling late English soul/pop singer Robert Palmer's 1978 hit Every Kinda People (which itself was patterned after Marvin Gaye's Mercy Mercy Me). Similarities between EKP and HCTN include tempo (EKP: 93bpm, HCTN 95bpm), production (steel drums, congas, guitar, bass, drum parts), and the rhythm of the melody for the steel drum part from EKP's chorus is very close to the rhythm of the vocal melody for HCTN's verse ("When you look at the sky, just try looking inside"). Every Kinda People (:43) and Here Comes The Night Time (6:08).
In "Royals", there is one part that stood out to me the first time I heard it. I immediately recalled the 8th track ("Home") from Dream Theater's "Metropolis Pt.2 - Scenes from a Memory" album. The similar sections are: In "Royals" - the hook after both verses (e.g. "gold teeth, grey goose, trippin' in the bathroom") and in "Home", the 1st verse ("Shine...lake of fire. Lines...take me higher"). Both sections are in D maj and the bpm is about the same. While the melodic line is different, the harmony is the same. There is also an absence of ringing instrumentals in both songs (only a chopping guitar riff in the Dream Theater song) so it feels similar too. [Home (2:38) and Royals (:33) -- ed. furtherlane]
The chorus to Lady Gaga's (Mother Monster's) dance/electronic chart-topper Applause (released August 12, 2013) bears some structural and lyrical resemblance to Vicki Sue Robinson's signature disco hit Turn The Beat Around (released 1976). Both songs have an identical descending minor chord progressions (I - Flat VII - VI or 1-b7-6) followed by ascension through the same chords. Turn The Beat Around starts in the key of F# minor, but modulates to G minor, the same key as Applause, and both songs cycle through the following progression: Gmin-Fmaj-Ebmaj-Ebmaj-Fmaj-Gmin. Turn the Beat Around is slightly slower than Applause (133 bpm versus 139 bpm). Compare TTBA (around 4:26, with the lines "Turn the beat around. Love to hear percussion.") and Applause (around :55, "Give me the thing that I love. I'll turn the lights out").
As a musician and composer, I’m often struck by similarities between pop songs. If you’ve ever listened to a tune on the radio and thought to yourself, “this sounds really familiar,” or “what does this melody remind me of,” (or more bluntly, “this song is a rip-off of …”) then you have shared in the experience.