The choruses to Imagine Dragons' song Demons (released October 22, 2013) and Madonna's hit Like a Prayer (March 3, 1989) have similar melodies (and lyrics). The opening line of LaP's chorus: "When you call my name" follows a 3-3-1-1-b7 melodic pattern, while the opening line of Demon's chorus: "When you feel my heart" follows a 3-3-5-1-b7 melodic pattern (only a single different interval, and two different words). Likewise, both melodies are sung over a I-V (or major 1-5) chord progression. LaP (key: F# major) follows a I-V-IV-I-V (or 1-5-4-1-5) progression and Demons (key: Eb major) follows a I-V-vi-IV (or 1-5-minor6-4) progression.
Honorable mention goes to the chorus to Crowded House's 1991 single Fall at Your Feet (:42), as Demons shares the same key (Eb) and exact (common) chord progression (I-V-vi-IV or 1-5-minor6-4), though melodies and tempos are distinct.
Check out the opening line of each chorus:
Like a Prayer (:42) vs Demons (:56)
Avril Lavigne's single Rock n Roll (released August 27, 2013) echos elements from Nirvana's Heart-Shaped Box (released August 30, 1993), as well as Joan Jett's version of I Love Rock 'n' Roll (released 1981) and Weezer's Beverly Hills (released March 29, 2005). Avril's track utilizes a classic rock rhythm that emphasizes eighth notes on the first and third beats of the measure (songs featuring this rhythm include: Jett's and Weezer's aforementioned tracks, Steve Miller's The Joker, Bad Company's Feel Like Making Love, Queen's We Will Rock You, the chorus to Def Leppard's Pour Some Sugar On Me, just to name a few). Avril's track emulates the production of I Love Rock 'n' Roll and Beverly Hills e.g. distorted guitar chord eighth notes on first and third beats, handclaps and big snare hits on two and four, punk glee club vocals. Likewise, in the chorus of Rock n Roll, Avril's "hey" shouts fall on the second and fourth beats of the measure, and glissando from an F to a G, just like Kurt Cobain's "hey"/"wait" shouts during the chorus of Heart-Shaped Box, which also gliss a whole step (from an F# to a G#). Listen to HSB (:49) vs RnR (1:42).
As a musician and composer, I’m often struck by similarities between pop songs. If you’ve ever listened to a tune on the radio and thought to yourself, “this sounds really familiar,” or “what does this melody remind me of,” (or more bluntly, “this song is a rip-off of …”) then you have shared in the experience.