The intro/chorus piano part to Hall of Fame by the Script featuring Will.i.am (August 19, 2012) has the same common chord progression (vi-IV-I-V or minor 6-4-1-5) as Alone by Heart (released May 16, 1987), albeit at slightly different tempos, and a half-step apart (HoF: Bb, Alone: C), and HoF's piano melody is similar to the vocal melody that Ann Wilson sings in Alone's chorus. Hall of Fame (:31) VS Alone (:50).
The verse to Ingrid Michaelson's Girls Chase Boys (released December 8, 1979) resembles to the bridge to Cody Simpson's Pretty Brown Eyes (released April 23, 2013). Both songs share a common chord progression (I-IV-vi-V or 1-4-minor6-5) in the same key: Ab, and each chord occupies a half-note per measure. Vocal melodies also have similar rhythmic values and play with the lyric "little" (GCB: "I'm a little let down, but I'm not dead"; PBE: "Spend a little bit of time with you"). Girls Chase Boys (:40) VS Pretty Brown Eyes (1:37).
Rixton's song Me and My Broken Heart (released March 14, 2014) interpolates the chorus vocal melody and chord progression to Rob Thomas' hit Lonely No More (released February 8, 2005). Thomas actually received a co-writing credit on Me and My Broken Heart. As Rixton lead singer Jake Roche explained in Billboard, "We've been a huge fan of [Thomas'], so we took a lot of inspiration from him and wanted to give him a tip of the hat." Me and My Broken Heart and Lonely No More both follow a i-iv-VII-III progression (MMBH in C minor, and LNM in A minor), and contain melodies that emphasize the fifth, sixth, and fourth degrees of the root scale. It's also worth noting that both songs echo the verse melody from Elton John's I'm Still Standing (released July 3, 1983).
Me and My Broken Heart (:58) VS Lonely No More (:42).
The chorus vocal melody for the Pixies' song Gigantic (released August 22, 1988, and featured in a recent iPhone 5S ad) is reminiscent of the chorus vocal melody to Kool and the Gang's 1983 R&B hit Joanna. Both melodies follow the same 5-2-1 progression (Gigantic in the key of G: D-A-G, and Joanna in the key of Bb: F-C-Bb), and share a similar rhythm i.e. each three-note melody starts on the second eighth note of the fourth beat (the "and" of four), followed by a longer note on the downbeat of the next measure (the "one"), and the final note on the upbeat in the same measure. Gigantic (:37) VS Joanna (1:18)
Other songs with melodies based around the fifth, second, and root degrees of the scale: the intro to Evergreen (Barbra Streisand), and the chorus to Lost In Love (Air Supply).
[Same tempo, drum beat, production/arrangement, though keys are a half-step apart (Bad Day: Eb; I Try: D), and relative chord progression differs. Bad Day (1:00) VS I Try (:47). edit - furtherlane.]
As a musician and composer, I’m often struck by similarities between pop songs. If you’ve ever listened to a tune on the radio and thought to yourself, “this sounds really familiar,” or “what does this melody remind me of,” (or more bluntly, “this song is a rip-off of …”) then you have shared in the experience.