The chorus vocal melody to Dublin-based quartet Kodaline's All I Want (released September 7, 2012) is reminiscent of the chorus vocal melody to Rod Stewart's Sailing (written by Gavin Sutherland, and released June 1972). The keys are only a half-step apart (All I Want: C, Sailing: B), and while the chord progressions differ slightly (AIW: vi-IV-I-V, Sailing: I-vi-IV-I), the relative diatonic melodies played over the minor 6 and root chords of each song are very similar (compare AIW: "But if you loved me" and Sailing: "Can you hear me?", and AIW: "Take my body" with "Far away"). Also, the melodies are rhythmically very similar, placing an emphasis on the first two quarter notes of each measure, and each chord change throughout the chorus, except for the last in Sailing, has a whole note value.
The chorus vocal melody from British singer-songerwriter Sam Smith's "Stay with Me" (released April 14, 2014) is reminiscent of the verse vocal melody to Tom Petty's "I Won't Back Down" (released April 1989). While I Won't Back Down (key: G) follows a vi-V-I (or minor6-5-1) chord progression, and Stay with Me (key: C) follows a vi-IV-I (or minor6-4-1) progression, their melodies are very similar (particularly the first two lines).
The chorus vocal melody to British singer-songerwriter Sam Smith's plaintive ballad "Stay with Me" (released April 14, 2014) is reminiscent of both the chorus vocal melody to Cyndi Lauper's signature hit "True Colors" (released July 25, 1986) and the verse vocal melody to Tom Petty's "I Won't Back Down" (released April 1989). While True Colors follows a IV-I-V (or 4-1-5) progression, and Stay with Me follows a vi-IV-I (or minor6-4-1) progression, both songs are in the same key (C), and the melodies closely parallel each other, TC: 1-3-5-6-6-5 "I see your true colors" compared with SwM: 1-3-5-6-5-3 "Oh won't you, stay with me".
The choruses to One Direction's "You & I" (released April 15, 2014) and Canadian rocker Bryan Adams' '80s ballad Heaven (released April 9, 1985) contain similar vocal melodies and chord progressions. Both songs start with the same relative chord structure: IV-V-vi-I-IV or 4-5-minor6-1-4, keys are only a half-step apart (Heaven: C, You & I: C#), and both have diatonic melodies that ascend with the first three chords (Heaven: 1-1-1-2-2-3-3-3-4-5-5-5-4-3-1; You & I: 1-2-3-3-3-3-3-5-1-1-6). Compare the lines, Heaven: "Baby you're all that I want/When you're lying here in my arms", and You & I: "You and I/We don't wanna be like them".
The chorus vocal melody for Tears for Fears' Mad World from their debut album The Hurting (released September 20, 1982) echoes the bridge vocal melody to Yusuf Islam's (the artist formerly known as Cat Stevens') Matthew and Son, the title track from his debut album (released March 10, 1967). Both sections feature the same exact melody over a ii-V (or minor2-5) chord progression, though in different keys (MW: E major; MaS: D major). Fun side note: Matthew and Sons features uncredited Led Zeppelin bassist John Paul Jones.
The chorus to Demi Lovato's single This Is Me (released June 6, 2008) from the Disney Camp Rock movie, is very similar to the chorus from Michelle Branch's hit Everywhere (released July 17, 2001). Similarities include: same key (C#), same chord progression (both songs follow a IV-I-V or 4-1-5) and production style.
As a musician and composer, I’m often struck by similarities between pop songs. If you’ve ever listened to a tune on the radio and thought to yourself, “this sounds really familiar,” or “what does this melody remind me of,” (or more bluntly, “this song is a rip-off of …”) then you have shared in the experience.